Skip to main content
| Bridget Vickers | News

Patriotism Is Not Nationalism

Two words

Call a man a patriot and, in many circles, you have already half-accused him of nationalism. The two words have been yoked together so thoroughly that to love England is treated as the first step toward an ideology of exclusion or supremacy.

Express a preference for the continuity of the language, the shape of the landscape, the habits of mind that once seemed ordinary, or the simple wish that the country remain recognisably itself, and the reply is often automatic: this is nationalism, thinly disguised. The man who objects is invited to prove a negative—to demonstrate that his attachment contains no trace of the forbidden creed. It is a clever trap. It shifts the burden of proof onto ordinary loyalty and leaves the more ambitious ideology free to borrow the moral capital of home and hearth.

The trap

The trap works best in a society that once took a high degree of cultural continuity for granted. For long periods England was, by European standards, unusually homogeneous in speech, law, and settled custom. In such conditions the everyday loyalty to place, language, and inherited ways felt almost indistinguishable from loyalty to the “nation” as a political abstraction. A man could love the shires, the common law, the sound of English speech, or the particular texture of English life without needing a theory of national destiny to justify himself.

The theory, when it appeared, often seemed only a louder and more systematic version of the same affection. The distinction between sentiment and ideology therefore remained largely academic. It was possible to move between the two without noticing the join.

History clarifies the difference

History makes the point clearer. In the late medieval and early modern periods, English attachment was commonly expressed as loyalty to the “community of the realm,” to the common law, to the crown as the guardian of established liberties, or simply to the land itself. Writers from the chroniclers to Shakespeare could speak of England with intense affection—“this sceptred isle,” “this blessed plot”—without advancing a doctrine that the English nation must be the supreme political principle or that its interests automatically outweighed every other claim. The sentiment was real and sometimes fierce; the modern nationalist programme was largely absent.

Contrast this with the nineteenth century on the Continent, where German and Italian nationalists had to invent or revive a political nation out of fragmented states and dialects. There the ideology had to be explicit, programmatic, and often aggressive precisely because homogeneity could not be assumed. England, already possessed of a continuous language, a unified legal tradition, and settled borders, had less need of such an ideology. What elsewhere required a theory could here pass as simple inheritance.

When homogeneity weakens

The same pattern appears in reverse when homogeneity weakens. George Orwell, writing in 1945, drew the distinction with unusual clarity: patriotism as attachment to a particular place and way of life, defensive in character; nationalism as the habit of identifying oneself with a single nation or other unit, placing it beyond good and evil, and recognising no other duty than that of advancing its interests. Orwell had watched both the generous patriotism of ordinary people in wartime Britain and the power-seeking nationalisms—British as well as foreign—that tried to conscript that feeling for ideological ends. The fact that he felt compelled to separate the two so carefully is itself evidence that the older, easier overlap was already under strain.

England is no longer in a position to treat the old overlap as harmless. The older, quieter word—patriotism—deserves to be rescued from the louder one.

Patriotism is the preference for one’s own country as a living inheritance: its speech, its landscape, its legal and literary memory, its particular habits of mind, the complicated and imperfect whole that actually exists. It can be critical, even elegiac. It does not require a doctrine of superiority or a political blueprint.

Nationalism, by contrast, is the elevation of the nation into a supreme political principle, usually accompanied by a programme for realising that supremacy—whether through the maximising of state power, the enforcement of cultural uniformity, or the ranking of national interest above every competing claim.

Patriotism and Nationalism can exist without the other

One can exist without the other. A man may love his country deeply and still reject the idea that the nation must be the measure of all things. Conversely, a nationalist programme can be advanced by people who show little evidence of ordinary affection for the place as it is.

Conflating the two does not make the soft word stronger; it only makes the hard word harder to examine. It blunts criticism of ideology by wrapping it in the prestige of loyalty, and it pathologises loyalty by treating it as latent ideology. The cost is paid in clarity. When every defence of inheritance is automatically translated into the language of nationalism, the possibility of a non-ideological attachment to England is quietly removed from the conversation. What remains is a choice between apologetic detachment and full-blown national doctrine—an unnecessarily stark choice, and one that serves neither the country nor the language in which we try to speak about it.

This piece sets out the difference with some care. It explains why relatively homogeneous societies are especially liable to miss the distinction, shows how the slippage operates in contemporary English debate, and asks what a clearer vocabulary would make possible. The argument is not that nationalism is always wicked or that patriotism is always pure. Both have been used for generous and for ugly ends. It is simply that they are not the same thing, and that pretending otherwise has become a habit we can no longer afford.

A country that can no longer rely on unspoken sameness needs spoken precision more, not less

 


Support Our Campaign

Patriotism Is Not Nationalism

| Bridget Vickers | News

The New English

| Bridget Vickers | News

The 2% Lie: Britain Is Selling 800 Years of Jury Justice for One Week's Delay

| Bridget Vickers | Articles
English Parliament

The New English

| Stephen Morris | News
What Devolution Has Done to England

What Devolution Has Done to England

| Bridget Vickers | News

The 2% Lie: England Is Selling 800 Years of Jury Justice for One Week's Delay

| Bridget Vickers | News

England's Poisoned Tap; How Privatised Water Became A National Scandal

| Bridget Vickers | News
The Celtic nations want independence

The Celtic nations want independence

| The CEP | News
Andy Burnham’s Devolution Plans Will Break England Apart

Andy Burnham’s Devolution Plans Will Break England Apart

| The CEP | News
Why Does England Need an English Parliament?

Why Does England Need an English Parliament?

| The CEP | News