Having England [and other nations] granted an opportunity to vote on their own constitutional future, next to any Scottish referendum, is entirely fair. Indeed, it confronts Labour with something amounting to a double-edged sword.

Clearly, Labour would not pursue such a vote in England, as they would state that it was simply not required nor asked for by the people. What do you think?

I agree with your taking Redwood to task over his ‘dual-mandate’ MPs, wonkotsane. The very notion is illogical: how can one MP have a mandate from two electorates – his local (English) constituents and all the people of the UK? If you’re going to separate out English / Scottish / Welsh / N. Irish legislative and policy programmes out from those that are still viewed as UK-wide, then you need separate elections to separate parliamentary bodies for each. Otherwise, it’s inevitable that the MPs in each country (Redwood’s idea is that Scottish MPs would also be dual-mandate: Westminster for three days and Holyrood for two) would just toe the UK-wide party line; and the differences in priorities, opinions and values on the part of their constituents and countries would not be adequately represented. Why bother with such an unworkable compromise solution? You might as well just bring the whole shooting match back to Westminster! Except of course, the Scottish genie has escaped from the bottle, and the English want a slice of self-government, too!

Can this wholly idiotic and divisive notion of Britishness be killed off though? The concept doesn’t stand up to any kind of scrutiny, at all.

LBB, of course you are right with Wendy Salamander’s tactics here. Leaving asides the fact that the woman is a complete imbecile and, week-in week-out demonstrates this with some alarming consistency [she was, and has always been, viciously keen to demonstrate how anti-referendum she is] I see her take as hugely flawed anyway.

1/ She can’t do it. Who the hell does she think she is? Thus far, the only party willing to ‘put it to the people’ and include ALL options are the SNP. Now, she [they didn't win by the way] has the audacity to suggest that Labour have always been in the same camp, when she’s only – as ever – pursuing Labour want. That asides…
2/ …if the referendum were to go, and the union prevailed [albeit with stronger powers for the parliament in Edinburgh] this notion of ’shooting the nationalist fox’ or ‘killing nationalism stone dead for a generation’ [have I heard that before? Mr.Robertson?] is simply wrong. Things, I suspect, would be rather closer than that, even with a union win. 35% to 40% would still mean Scottish Independence was on the cards. Further…
3/ …referendum asides, people might just decide that the SNP make a better bloody government than Labour anyway. Which they do, as it happens.

I remain disgusted by Labour/Liberal/Tory unionist politicians, in every way, in Scotland. Though at least Ms.Goldie – though wrong – is at least likable. Just the same way you guys must feel in regard to ‘British’ MPs doing their utmost for England. Not.

Personally I would love to see a referendum on independence for England. The benefits for England especially if at the same time we leave the European Union are enormous. First off is the money I reckon about £60-80 billion better off, then there are the jobs, the Royal Naval maintenance of ships would move to Devonport, Rosyth would close as it would be uneconomic for Scotland. The submarine base would move to Cumbria and RAF stations whose job is now done in Scotland would move to the North-East. Many other jobs would move back into England The Royal Mint and Vehicle Licensing centre for two. Farmers would be unhindered by EU rules.

Unfortunately there arn’t any UK MP’s representing English constituencies, that will stick their head above the parapet in Englands defence, the Labour ones know they would never be elected again, and the Tory’s are all “dyed in the wool” Unionists who are afraid of being booted out of the Conservative party by “Scottish blood in my veins” Cameron if they don’t toe the party line, including Redwood.

There will be no resolution utill we see blood on the carpet, metaphorically speaking.

I guess I would further repeat that Gordon Brown has no more interest for Scotland [other than what is required when you're pushing through absolute insistence on a British state] than Lloyd Grossman does in a marmite toastie. As I hope his feverish and panicked soul is ably demonstrating just now as his precious union is seemingly being put to the sword by his own.

Scottish Labour – more U-turns than La Mons. They are – singly – a party with only their OWN interest and twisted doctrine at heart. I’m glad they are getting pummeled both sides of the border.

It was only a matter of time before half-wits like Redwood start belly aching about any vote on Scottish Independence being open to everyone, including the Scots. And I respect your remarks to that end Wonko. It is ludicrous.

Just as ludicrous as the situation England finds itself in. I suppose part of this frustration is that a nationalist party is in power in Scotland, whereas England’s nationalist efforts are barley scrapping the knuckles of the 300 or so ‘British’ representatives England has voted in.

So can I ask you a question Wonko? And this is for my own knowledge. How many English MPs have expressed – formally – a desire for an English parliament? I know public support is rightly there [in England and Scotland!] but what are the numbers?

I guess I would add that I’m in favour of English Independence – not a federal union, or any other bizarre and unworkable scenario.

I do wonder what Scottish Labour’s strategy would be when Mr.Cameron becomes the next UK prime minister? Doubtless, it will involve the Labour ‘bogey man’ stories again. Something along the lines of ‘..you better vote Labour to stop the evil Tory Genie hurting Scotland again…oooooo…oooooooo’.

Except this time, a Labour vote in Scotland in a UK general election might be about as useful as a chocolate fireguard, given that England will quickly dispatch them anyway.

Interesting times.